Local News

SAN FRANCISCO (CBS 5 / AP) ― More California voters now support allowing same-sex marriage than oppose it, according to a new Field Poll released Wednesday.

The poll of 1,052 registered voters found that 51 percent of respondents backed legalizing same-sex marriage and 42 percent opposed it.

However, the Field Poll's finding conflicts with two other recent polls.

A Los Angeles Times poll of 705 voters released last week that found 54 percent backed a proposed gay marriage ban likely to be on the November ballot and 35 percent opposed it.

Another poll recently conducted for CBS 5 by Survey USA of 500 adults found 52 percent would support the ban if it's on the ballot, while 36 percent would oppose it.

The Field Poll questioned people separately on the proposed ballot initiative. Field asked respondents about it two ways—once referencing the specific measure a group is seeking to get on the November ballot and once talking about a gay marriage ban amendment more generally.

Fifty-four percent opposed the amendment when presented with the issue generally, a figure that dropped to 51 percent when respondents were told they might have the chance to vote on a specific measure in November. Support for the amendment stood at 40 percent and 43 percent.

All three polls, Field, L.A. Times and CBS 5, were conducted after the California Supreme Court handed down its historic ruling legalizing same-sex marriage in the nation's most populous state.

A smaller percentage of Field Poll respondants—48 percent—said they agreed with the court's decision and 46 percent disagreed. The CBS 5 poll found repondants divided over the court ruling—46 percent each agreed and disagreed with the ruling.
 
Field Poll director Mark DiCamillo said these latest Field Poll results marked the first time in over three decades of his organization's surveys that more California voters have approved of extending marriage to gay couples than have disapproved.

"I would say this is a historic turning point or milestone," DiCamillo said. "We have speculated in the past there would be some time in the future when a majority would support same-sex marriage. Well, the lines have crossed."

In 2006, when participants were asked, "Do you approve or disapprove of California allowing homosexuals to marry members of their own sex?" 44 percent said they approved and 50 percent objected. In 1977, the first year Field posted the question to voters, 28 percent approved and 59 percent were opposed.

DiCamillo said the jump in support for same-sex marriage indicates that voters were "influenced in some way by the judgment of the high court."
"I am left to surmise that had some impact on voters who might have been on the fence or marginally opposed," he said.

DiCamillo said the numbers could change once the amendment qualifies for the ballot, but the early results indicate "the concept itself is not widely embraced."

The Field survey had a margin of sampling error of plus or minus four percentage points on the general amendment question, and plus or minus five percentage points on the more specific question.

Andrew Pugno, legal adviser for the coalition of religious and social conservative groups sponsoring the measure, said the Times and CBS 5 polls are more consistent with his group's internal polling.

"We could acknowledge there has been increasing acceptance of the idea of gay relationships over the last 10 or 20 years, but we think when it comes to marriage there is still a solid majority who want to see it reserved for a man and a woman, and that is all this initiative is about," Pugno said.

(© 2009 CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)